Call us at
1-800-219-5332
Contractors Join Our Network

Bryn Mawr II by Certainteed Reviews

based on 2 reviews

 

Overall quality: 4
Locks: 3
Balance System: 4
Warranty: 5

November 13th 2010 at 4:49 am

Window Comments

I looked at 4 different windows from 4 different companies. Pella version from Lowes-Local contractor install. Simonton version from Home Depot Simonton from a local contractor CertainTeed from a local contractor While the Simontons did look like good windows, they were not significantly better in any way then the CertainTeeds. There was a noticable quality difference and feature difference between the Simontons,CertainTeeds and the Lowes version Pellas though. In the end, the CertainTeeds won out in the quality and value for money categories. The actual windows installed were the MI Xacts which are the identical model to the Bryn MawrIII CertainTeeds now made by MI in Gratz,PA.

Window Grade: 4.0
Install Comments

Installed by Local Contractor of NJ

The installer was a local contractor but via references, he had installed thousands of windows in the area and in the Philly area as well. His work was precise, neat and clean. He took his time and did the job right. He trimmed all the interior with primed trim and I did the interior caulking and touch-up as agreed. I couldn't be more pleased with the installation. The windows look and work great!!

Install Grade: 5.0
Price Information

I was quoted a fair price I believe. $3580 for 9 windows.

Overall quality: 3
Locks: 3
Balance System: 3
Warranty: 3

September 27th 2007 at 12:02 am

Window Comments

This was the fully welded line of Certainteed double hung windows so is at least better than the Devon line. These were also Argon filled with a low-e coating. They seem to save me a great deal of money on electricity during AC season which makes me really happy but I'm not sure they save me much on my fuel oil bill during the winter - they probably do but its not as significant as the summer. Even given that positive, personally, I will probably never go with vinyl replacement windows again if I get another house. My perception of them now is that they are cheap and cheesy plastic and I can't see the installation really being that much different with new construction windows. This could also have a great deal to do with the people installing them but I can't get over the overall cheap feeling and loss of glass area over a regular window. They work great, they open and close easily so I don't really have any complaints there except the mechanism that the window tilts on and slides on was messed up on one of the windows on one side. Also, this window has a molded-in handle to lift the window which is at least better than screw-on handles, I think, but the edges on these should have been sanded down because they really can cut you. I also got a custom 5 panel bow that was pretty big and a another large window that also cranks outward two panes - can't remember what that's called (casement?). The impressive thing with these is the ease of the crank operation. It takes no effort to open these windows. The best advice that I can give and next time I will do this - you must physically see a window unit and pick it up and operate it and compare it to other manufacturers - this is very important. See it both loose and installed. I'm not even sure how or where you can do this but next time I buy windows I've got to see them and touch them before making a decision. As far as Certainteed is concerned, the company has been around for awhile but I don't know how their warranty works or even what it is. Would I buy these windows again? I suppose it could happen but I'd be looking closely at many other alternatives.

Window Grade: 3.0
Install Comments

Installed by 1 Call Remodeling of NY

The worst contractor experience I have ever had. We had a package deal of roof, siding and windows but I'll focus on the windows. First of all, my advice is to not go with someone who does all three and does not specialize. The contractor is used to the windows they install and anything else is really beyond their scope. This guy spec'd the Devon line and did not understand why I wanted the Bryn Mawr line. He was only interested in putting in basic windows and did not really want to discuss doing anything interesting with different window styles - for example, I wanted to replace the two doublehung dining room windows with a large window that cranks out two panes from the middle so its a large window only split vertically. It was like pulling teeth to get him to discuss options. Likewise, many of the doublehungs being replaced were two windows next to each other so I wanted to know if it could be replaced with two windows built as a single unit versus two separate windows. The answer was yes but again he did not want to deal with anything complicated at first - and this was with no changes to the existing openings. I'd recommend going with someone who understands windows and can talk about options. Also, if they say something like "Oh, I have two or three different brands I use", pin them down or better yet, find someone who knows what they are doing. As far as installation is concerned, the windows have instructions included with them and 1Call did not follow those instructions. I even called Certainteed but they really don't care - they don't certify installers and have no mechanism to check on or review people installing their windows. The answer from 1Call is that this is how they do it. I do not feel that the windows are insulated enough around windows (air leaks in through the screw holes where the window is screwed to the framing) and to ensure that it was sealed, they caulked in a 1/4" x 1" strip of wood on the inside of the window around the perimeter. This does not replace adequate insulation. Also, trim was not included in the deal and I understood that but what they did with the 1/4" strip made putting the old trim up look horrible. In some rooms they put the old trim back and it was done poorly. In some rooms they "did me a favor" and trimmed the windows. In actuality, it was such a poor job it will cost me more money to make it look nice. This is probably the biggest reason I don't see the advantages of vinyl replacement windows over regular but then again, I did not get a quote on the alternatives. Also, one of the window panes was broken when installed and they sent a Devon window instead of a Bryn Mawr and refused to accept the fact they there were different - his supplier told him they were the same but you can visibly see the difference. Also, I guess either because this guy was used to ordering Devon or because his supplier was used to him ordering Devon, that's what showed up in my yard one day instead of the Bryn Mawr. To make it worse, they never would have known, I had to check the shipment myself and tell him that the wrong stuff was delivered. Don't let your contractor walk all over you. Contracts tell you what is included but do not tell you what is not included that might seem obvious - like trim. Check. I'm not sure if this is normal but try not to let someone put in a 'not responsible for incidental damage from vibrations, etc' clause. Make it clear that if they break something or their negligence causes a problem, its their responsibility to fix it. I've not signed too many contractor contracts so maybe that's a normal clause that you can't get out of.

Install Grade: 1.0
Price Information

The initial quote was a standard quote of something like $440 per windows installed and capped but that was for Devon so I was charged a bit more than that and had an expensive 10' x 5' 5 panel bow.

Review this product yourself!

Window Consumer Infomation

Abcleads.com BBB Business Review   Member of NAHB

Current Board Posts

  • Tuesday September 19, 2017

    Understanding Energy Star regions

    I am shopping for DH vinyl replacements. I have narrowed my choices to Okna, Sunrise and Vytex products. I live in the Raleigh...

  • Sunday September 17, 2017

    Replacement windows comparison

    I'm replacing 4 windows in my master bedroom. I live in the suburbs of Chicago. My bedroom faces southwest, so it bakes in...

  • Friday September 15, 2017

    egress and normal casements

    I’m familiar with normal hinged casements but I have never operated an egress casement. A benefit of an egress is a full,...

  • Tuesday September 12, 2017

    Recommendations in Philadelphia, PA

    Hello,
    I'm in Philadelphia and looking for a window replacement recommendation. I'm replacing aluminum windows that function but look terrible. My priorities are...

  • Sunday September 10, 2017

    pella 250 windows opinions

    Which product are you looking at inside of their line...

  • Saturday September 9, 2017

    opinions on pella 250 double pane double hung

    i am a newbie with a few questions i am looking for replacement vinyl windows for my house and have looked at a...

  • Sunday September 10, 2017

    Installer recommendations in Charlotte, NC area

    We addressed a completely rotted interior MDF stool this week in which I didn't even utilize any kind of pry bar as my...

  • Sunday September 3, 2017

    snap in flanges, extruded flanges

    Okna new constructions have a nailing flange that is part of the frame. The flange is extruded with the frame at the...

  • Wednesday August 30, 2017

    casement windows... possibly marquee

    PLEASE HELP>>> I built a home in elkhart IN 46517 in 2003 from I believe a company named elkhart window and siding. I...

  • Friday August 18, 2017

    Polaris Unishield vs Simonton Vantage Point 6500

    I live in NJ and am trying to figure out a reasonable and reliable double hung replacement window for several of our windows...

1 of 10

Do it Yourself- Replacement Window Video