Call us at
Contractors Join Our Network

Please Visit our New Replacement Windows Board

 Go to Top  |  Go to Topic  |  Search   Newer Topic  |  Older Topic 

 Simont vs. Milgard

Author: hillyut (

Hello, I live in the South Bay area of CA. We are looking for windows, and initially were going to go with Polybau and the Window Broker, but have decided not to. Now I am trying to decide between Milgard and Simonton. I like the feature on Simonton that allows you to open the window partially (I have small children). I just can't seem to see if Milgard is more expensive because of the name, or if there's something better there.


 Re: Simont vs. Milgard

Author: kris (

simonton impressions (if thats what you're comparing) to either milgard classic or styleline has silicon spacer, double strength glass and cleaner sitelines. imho i feel milgard vinyl windows are over-rated.


 Re: Simont vs. Milgard

Author: mss (

call your alside dist and ask for their preservation window same price much better window


 Re: Simont vs. Milgard

Author: Benny (

I got a chance to see one in person, and I will agree that the preservation is a very nice window (higher end for sure), and the specs are impressive overall, but the quote for 12 windows in my house came out to be around $6000 higher than a quote I received for simonton 9800's.
IMHO, there wasn't anything revolutionary about them that made them worth the extra expense compared to the simontons. In fact, I know from seeing the sample window, that the simonton (even my 5500's have it) have shadow cut grooves at the corners of the sashes (very clean looking), where the preservations do not, and I believe that superspacer (and of course TPS) is not available with the alside window (I could be wrong on this though, but I remember asking the salesman about it and he seemed to not know if it was available)

Maybe my area is priced higher, but the salesperson even offered the standard "I can give you a % discount if you do the work cause we're slow" deal, and it was still too high. For that kind of money, I'd go schuco though.

 Threaded View   Newer Topic  |  Older Topic 

Window Consumer Infomation BBB Business Review   Member of NAHB

Current Board Posts

  • Friday April 29, 2016

    Vinyl Patio Door w/ Built-In Blinds

    I'm in the market for a new back door (patio). My research has lead me to lean towards vinyl to avoid all the...

  • Monday April 25, 2016

    Deepest gratitude

    I just want to thank everyone on this site. Not only the pro's who take time out from their busy days to...

  • Wednesday April 20, 2016

    Provia Aspect windows

    Hi All,
    Does anyone have an opinion on Provia Aspect vinyl windows? I'm thinking of replacing the single pane windows in my...

  • Wednesday April 20, 2016

    A lot to learn

    Hi all,
    I am slowly learning there are a ton of issues and questions with getting new windows. Can I ask you...

  • Tuesday April 19, 2016

    Help appreciated muchly. NC replacement windows.

    What do you think about Atrium 3000 windows, 22 installed for 8, 800 bucks. This is Eastern NC. I live in San...

  • Tuesday April 19, 2016

    Atrium 3000

    I am sorry I am unable to figure out how to search this board. Can anyone give me an opinion regarding Atrium...

  • Friday April 15, 2016

    Replacement Vinyl Windows by EngryWeld

    Any information on EngryWeld windows and Engry Tec Patio...

  • Monday April 11, 2016

    Okna 500DX and 800DX - same glass, diff ratings?

    Curious why the NFRC ratings differ (albeit minimally) between the Okna 500DX and the 800DX when the glass packs are the same? Is...

  • Monday April 11, 2016

    Okna Insul-tec vs Window world series 4000

    +1. You are considering products at opposite ends of the spectrum, so a $100 spread per unit is not difficult to justify IMO....

  • Saturday April 9, 2016

    Pella 350 or something else?

    I am about to order Pella 350, tripple glass, low_E with Argon windows, frame filled with foam. They are about 4x4'.

1 of 10

Do it Yourself- Replacement Window Video