Call us at
Contractors Join Our Network

Please Visit our New Replacement Windows Board

 Go to Top  |  Go to Topic  |  Search   Previous Message  |  Next Message 

 Anlin Vs. Polybau Vs. Amerimax

Author: Thomas (

I do product analysis for computer security products for a living, so I thought figuring out which windows to put in my house would be easy. WRONG!! What a nightmare. Even with reading this site (Hundreds of posts) clarily remains elusive.

So, The 3 brands I'm liking best (with Certainteed a 'maybe') are Anlin, Polybau, and Amerimax. This is based on looking at the windows, hearing the pitch, making an Excel spreadsheet matrix of features and scratching my head a lot. Oh, and let's not forget price and installation quality.

All have a SuperSpacer type seal with Anlin having a new version that uses Silicon with three chambers rather than the material traditionally used. Same mylar and Butyl layers in all three.

U-values and heat gain are all pretty close and in the end may not be a deciding factor. Argon is a question. I don't need its insulation capacity in San Francisco, but I've read it extends the life of the E-glass coating.

Vinyl!! Thickness and composition (like titanium dioxide concentration) is really hard to get data for. Help please!! And the structural rating (R-35 or R-25 etc.) is a new one I was just told about. Where do you find that data?

Warranty: all have lifetime material and vary for labor from lifetime down to 5 yrs (Certainteed).

Some details like weephole covers, sloping angle for drainage system, roller material (brass vs. nylon) and whether it is adjustable or not, number of window seals (2 or 3 are on the list. Which really matter?

So, I've done my homework but there are gaps in my answers and no final conclusion. I sure hope I can get some help from you guys. Which of these items REALLY matter if I want a window to last 25 years. Which are just minor details or aesthetic? Thanks.

 Flat View   Newer Topic  |  Older Topic 

 Topics Author  Date
 Anlin Vs. Polybau Vs. Amerimax  new
 Re: Anlin Vs. Polybau Vs. Amerimax  new

Window Consumer Infomation BBB Business Review   Member of NAHB

Current Board Posts

  • Wednesday November 18, 2015

    Reasonable Pricing

    Folks, I'm still trying to get past the first part of my window nightmare....
    I agreed to buy 16 Openings/25 Windows as follows....

  • Wednesday November 18, 2015

    Working with the companies on this board

    I'm a customer (not a contractor) who has found this board very helpful in identifying quality windows and contractor practices. Even asked questions...

  • Sunday November 15, 2015

    Rain after window installation

    Hi, I have a few questions about some windows that were replaced. Yesterday we had 7 windows replaced in our home with 3...

  • Monday November 9, 2015

    old vinyl window

    Hi all!
    I have a question to prfessionals. I have an old vinyl window in my garage. It became yellowish. I do not...

  • Thursday November 5, 2015

    To Cap or not to cap

    I have had two different opinions provided by two different highly rated contractors in my area. We bought our home a year...

  • Wednesday November 4, 2015

    Synergy NGT

    I had a local contractor that is highly rated on Angie's list provide me a quote today for some options to replace 5...

  • Tuesday November 3, 2015

    Burris replacement windows (Texas)

    hey guys so I'm trying to replace the windows in my house (32 windows) and I'm considering going with Burris windows. I've done...

  • Monday November 2, 2015

    Need help finding a window in Louisiana

    I have been doing lots of research to try to find some great windows for my house I'm renovating. It it hot and...

  • Thursday October 29, 2015

    HD v Lowes v Sears

    I just got three estimates from them. Home Depot 6100 VantagePoint by Simonton. Lowes Pella 250series and Sears Weatherbeater.
    With the prices...

  • Friday October 23, 2015

    VinylMax replacement windows

    We are trying VinylMax out for first time by recommendation through Lyf-Tym Building Supply in Hickory, NC. However, right out the gate, we...

1 of 10

Do it Yourself- Replacement Window Video