Call us at
Contractors Join Our Network

Please Visit our New Replacement Windows Board

 Go to Top  |  Go to Topic  |  Search   Previous Message  |  Next Message 

 Anlin Vs. Polybau Vs. Amerimax

Author: Thomas (

I do product analysis for computer security products for a living, so I thought figuring out which windows to put in my house would be easy. WRONG!! What a nightmare. Even with reading this site (Hundreds of posts) clarily remains elusive.

So, The 3 brands I'm liking best (with Certainteed a 'maybe') are Anlin, Polybau, and Amerimax. This is based on looking at the windows, hearing the pitch, making an Excel spreadsheet matrix of features and scratching my head a lot. Oh, and let's not forget price and installation quality.

All have a SuperSpacer type seal with Anlin having a new version that uses Silicon with three chambers rather than the material traditionally used. Same mylar and Butyl layers in all three.

U-values and heat gain are all pretty close and in the end may not be a deciding factor. Argon is a question. I don't need its insulation capacity in San Francisco, but I've read it extends the life of the E-glass coating.

Vinyl!! Thickness and composition (like titanium dioxide concentration) is really hard to get data for. Help please!! And the structural rating (R-35 or R-25 etc.) is a new one I was just told about. Where do you find that data?

Warranty: all have lifetime material and vary for labor from lifetime down to 5 yrs (Certainteed).

Some details like weephole covers, sloping angle for drainage system, roller material (brass vs. nylon) and whether it is adjustable or not, number of window seals (2 or 3 are on the list. Which really matter?

So, I've done my homework but there are gaps in my answers and no final conclusion. I sure hope I can get some help from you guys. Which of these items REALLY matter if I want a window to last 25 years. Which are just minor details or aesthetic? Thanks.

 Flat View   Newer Topic  |  Older Topic 

 Topics Author  Date
 Anlin Vs. Polybau Vs. Amerimax  new
 Re: Anlin Vs. Polybau Vs. Amerimax  new

Window Consumer Infomation BBB Business Review   Member of NAHB

Current Board Posts

  • Sunday October 4, 2015

    A major force, large missile test, pelvic pieces of glass

    A major force, large missile test, pelvic pieces of glass, which is subject to driving at a speed of 34 miles per hour....

  • Thursday October 1, 2015

    Reverse cottage style windows

    I live in the Chicagoland area and am on the search for replacement windows. We live in a brick faced ranch and...

  • Thursday October 1, 2015

    Polaris V. Simonton V. Reliabilt

    We are looking at replacing our old Traco windows that came with our house. So far, our options are: Polaris Thermalweld (or...

  • Tuesday September 29, 2015

    New Windows Comparison in Connecticut

    Hello, I am new to the group looking for some basic feedback. I am currently looking to replace roughly 34 windows in my...

  • Monday September 28, 2015

    WASCO vs. Sunrise Windows - Vinyl Replacements

    Hello! We have three questions about vinyl replacement windows for original 1960's interior windows and separate exterior storms...
    1. Looking to...

  • Wednesday September 23, 2015

    Ok, last one...

    I have a quote for 23 double hung Softlite Imperial LS windows installed for $504.50 each. Is this a good...

  • Tuesday September 22, 2015

    elements really that good for the money

    Wow...seems like after tons of reading the soft lite elements are a real hit in the "high end" side of replacement windows.

  • Sunday September 20, 2015

    satisfied/happy customers in cincinnati

    Can anyone help me with their recommendations of replacement window dealers/installation companies in Cincinnati?
    I have narrowed it down to 3

  • Sunday September 20, 2015

    good price on soft lite windows and provia door

    here is the deal
    15-soft lite elements double hung ultra s glass triple pane windows $8150
    all windows under 100 total inches...

  • Saturday September 19, 2015

    Quick show of hands...

    I promise this will be my last post....(maybe)... I have narrowed the field to three choices:
    1. Insignia windows & ProVia doors

1 of 10

Do it Yourself- Replacement Window Video